Menu of NYC Pizza South in Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 11003 S Memorial Dr in Tulsa, NYC Pizza South delivers an authentic slice of New York with every bite. This pizza joint expertly captures the essence of NYC-style pizza, boasting a thin, flavorful crust that resonates with longtime New Yorkers and pizza aficionados alike. The thin crust is a standout—light yet sturdy, with just the right chewiness and a subtle crisp edge that holds up well under generous toppings.

The menu offers more than just pizza. House specialties like the Manicotti ($8.40), Calzones ($7.95), and Italian Rolls ($7.96) provide a satisfying variety for those craving classic Italian-American comfort food. These dishes showcase a dedication to traditional recipes, blending rich sauces and fresh ingredients with skill. The dessert offerings don't go unnoticed either—Cannoli and Tiramisu round out the experience with authentic sweetness, leaving a lasting impression after the meal.

Customer feedback underscores the quality and service: Justin Nauss praises the "meat lovers" pizza as the best NYC-style he's had in years, highlighting the aromatic spices that linger long after the last bite. Mark Hellmann Regouby emphasizes the genuine NYC vibe, noting that this is the "real deal" for authentic thin crust in Tulsa. While Jacob Skidmore points out that the crust and pizzas could benefit from a slightly longer bake for optimal texture, he still found the flavor compelling, and the staff welcoming and engaging.

Personally, I appreciate how NYC Pizza South captures both the nostalgic and the contemporary in its dishes. The garlic knots, though dense, burst with garlic flavor that complements each slice perfectly, while the clean, inviting atmosphere makes dining comfortable and enjoyable. The balance between traditional pizza-making techniques and a warm customer experience makes this restaurant a must-try for anyone craving classic New York pizza without leaving Oklahoma.

In summary, NYC Pizza South is a beacon of authenticity in Tulsa’s pizza landscape. Its thin crust, well-crafted house specialties, and classic desserts come together to form a cohesive menu that pays homage to Italian-American culinary traditions. Whether you’re after a slice or a full meal, the quality, flavor, and friendly service make it worth multiple visits.